Skip to main content

Initial Governance Model with Promoter Leadership

AgrospAI will be based on an Organizational Governance system that will involve coordination, decision-making, and objective setting within the data space and will promote collaboration among multiple stakeholders. A Data Space Authority will be established, which will act as the entity responsible for operating and maintaining said governance, including managing disputes between participants.

This authority, at least during the demonstration period, will be the Universitat de Lleida as the data space operator. Later, it will evolve towards shared governance with participants, and options will be explored to establish an alternative Data Space Authority, compatible with also making the operator's role sustainable, for example, as a new independent entity.

On the other hand, there is Data Sharing Governance, which regulates access to data and processing services among participants. The data operator, as the governance authority, will establish the initial rules with the requirements for incorporating participants into the demonstrator and the products and services available therein.

Initially, participants will be those listed at the beginning of this section who have already shown interest in the project by signing the letters of support attached to this application. The letters are based on a model that defines the requirements and benefits of being a participant in the demonstrator. From this initial set of participants, new participants will be incorporated, prioritizing those who complement existing use cases or who allow defining new data space use cases.

For new use cases, priority will be given to those that leverage the demonstrator's capabilities, especially those with trust requirements that can be resolved with the sovereignty-by-design functionality through data computation. Also, those that show greater potential thanks to the monetization capabilities also provided by the demonstrator.

Furthermore, regarding data and processing services, governance will define the rules to follow when sharing data. In addition to being related to the agri-food sector, it will be essential to comply with the regulatory framework established at national and European levels.

To maximize interoperability both within the demonstrator's data space and with those it will interoperate with, those of the Pontus-X ecosystem, but also others that use Gaia-X data space federation tools, the governance structure will be organized into 2 levels: a Global Governance that will harmonize interoperability between different data spaces and a specific governance body for the demonstrator, AgrospAI Governance.

Global Governance​

Global Governance will primarily be that of the Pontus-X ecosystem as the entity responsible for defining interoperability rules among the data spaces within this ecosystem. Governance is exercised collaboratively by all participants in the role of “federators,” as shown in Fig. 1.

It is also relevant to mention the participation of many Pontus-X members in the governance bodies of Gaia-X Europe, and the interest of that ecosystem in aligning with Gaia-X specifications and components for data space federation.

Finally, although the project for the implementation of the future Common European Agricultural Data Space (CEADS) will not begin until 2025, the results of the preparatory project AgriDataSpace (in which the Universitat de Lleida participated) already propose its future governance model based on a Network Administrative Organization (NAO). The evolution of the CEADS implementation project will be followed during 2025 to explore options for integrating AgrospAI into its NAO.

Fig. 1 Fig. 1. Pontus-X ecosystem members and their governance structure (source: deltaDAO AG)

AgrospAI Governance​

Aligned with Global Governance, inherited from the ecosystems of which AgrospAI will be a part (Pontus-X, Gaia-X, and the future CEADS), governance will also be carried out at the demonstrator level. The roles within AgrospAI Governance will be:

  • Ecosystem promoter: the Universitat de Lleida would be responsible, at least initially, for its governance and for defining and executing the system's registration and deregistration processes, as well as its supervision.
  • Technology provider: the Pontus-X provider, presumably deltaDAO AG.
  • Intermediation service providers: deltaDAO AG and Arsys.
  • Data space operator: Universitat de Lleida but also those entities that operate the data computation intermediation service. Initially Arsys but open to any operator with computational resources who wishes to commercialize through the data space.
  • Providers and consumers: those participants who have signed the letter of support as previously indicated.

It is also important to identify the actors indirectly involved in this governance by forming the development communities for the components used by AgrospAI and the data spaces it would interoperate with. Specifically, the development communities of Gaia-X, Eclipse, Pontus-X, and Ocean Protocol, all based on open source. And finally, global interoperability and trust service providers, mainly the different GXDCH providers.

Regarding the demonstrator's organizational model, it will be organized following a network model. Collaboration among all participants will be based on consensus, reciprocity, and the pursuit of collective goals and benefits. But data space governance is not something static, unchangeable over time, but rather should be understood as continuously evolving.

Within this model, considering how its governance is managed, it will begin by following a leadership governance, where the promoter will act as the central coordinator. Throughout the project's demonstrator phase, it will evolve towards shared governance, where the relevance of each decision will depend on the level of participant involvement. Nearing the end of the demonstrator phase, and looking towards the future sustainability of the data space, the future governance will be decided collaboratively through a Network Administrative Organization (NAO), a neutral coordination body.

As mentioned, AgrospAI will begin its journey following a leadership governance model, exercised by the demonstrator promoter at least during the funded demonstrator phase. This model is detailed in Section 4.

Leadership Governance Model​

AgrospAI's initial governance model, based on leadership by the demonstrator's promoter, addresses the aspects detailed in the following subsections.

Organizational Interoperability​

Data space participants and roles​

Intermediation service provider role: for data computation or GXDCH. Open to any provider that meets the demonstrator's requirements regarding these components and guarantees of independence, especially within the DGA framework.

Openness to new participants: open to any economic agent in the agri-food sector. Admission rules based on technological criteria described in interoperability standards. Also, complementarity regarding the use cases deployed in the demonstrator, or the potential for deploying new use cases relevant to the Spanish agri-food sector.

Business models​

Business autonomy for providers and consumers who, within the options allowed by smart contract implementation, have complete business autonomy regarding terms of use and their acceptance.

Interrelation with other data spaces​

Operation of the demonstrator within the decentralized network of the Pontus-X ecosystem. Users of the demonstrator can interrelate with other data spaces in the ecosystem, including cross-sectoral relationships.

Semantic Interoperability​

Service offer description​

Variety of representable resources, as it allows describing different resources (data, applications for data exploitation, and computational resources).

Flexibility in service description, within the Gaia-X Trust Framework and the vocabularies it defines for describing data and processing services.

Definition of offer resources using recognized standards, also in the context of the Gaia-X Trust Framework.

Data Sovereignty​

Definition of resource usage and access policies: the data space will initially rely on the information model of existing smart contracts within the Pontus-X framework to define resource access and usage policies. During the project, options will be explored to integrate them with the access policy languages that will be established within the Gaia-X framework.

Formats​

Open W3C standard formats for Verifiable Credentials (VC) for modeling information about participants and the data and services they share.

Conformity​

Use of the Gaia-X Digital Clearing House (GXDC) as a conformity service that will guarantee the validity of the formal composition and content of credentials for participants and for the descriptions of the data and services they share.

Technological Interoperability​

Data space architecture​

Architecture based on digital data federation and integrated into the data federation network provided by the open-source licensed specifications and components of the Pontus-X ecosystem and the Gaia-X initiative.

Solution components​

Components made available in open-source format within the framework of the Ocean Protocol initiative (on which the Pontus-X ecosystem is based), Gaia-X, Eclipse Dataspace Components (EDC), and Eclipse Cross Federation Services Components (XFSC) are reused.